Best Tasting Cat Foods For Picky Cats In 2021 Reviews & Top Picks
Being the owner of a picky cat can leave you working tirelessly to find the perfect things for your feline friend. Whether its food, toys, beds, or cat litter, giving your cat what they want can make both your lives so much easier. This is especially true when it comes to food. Picky cats are known to turn up their nose at foods they dont like. No amount of begging from you will help the situation. The only way back into your cats good graces is to find a food they enjoy with great nutritional value.
To help on your mission of pleasing your cat, weve found the 10 best cat foods for picky cats. Look at the list below, pull out your wallet, and prepare to tempt your kitty with a taste of these foods until the true master of the house chooses their favorite.
Buying Guide For Best Wet Cat Foods
High in moisture and packed with protein, wet cat food mirrors a cats natural diet. Most vets recommend it, and some cats insist on it. Whether youre looking for the best cat food for a new kitten or simply want to ensure that your feline friends are getting the nourishment they need, wet cat food is an excellent choice. But with so many different recipes, textures, and flavours to choose from, where do you start?
If you need a hand finding the best wet cat food for your furbaby, youve come to the right place. At BestReviews, we aim to simplify every shopping experience. Weve put in hours of research and waded through the vast array of wet cat food options currently on the market to help you find the purrfect fit for your kitty.
Why Are Cats Fussy Eaters
Before you even attempt to find the best cat food for fussy eaters, its important to answer the question: why are cats fussy eaters? Are they really that picky? Do they, like humans, like to experiment with their taste palate? Or are allergies the reason for your cats complaints?
Cats actually have far less taste sensors than a dog, so why are they so picky? This is because a cat, unlike a dog, is unable to metabolise in their body some critical nutrients required for good health. Perhaps the most important of these is natural taurine. As natural taurine is so crucial for a cat, their senses have become finally tuned to detect natural taurine in their food. You can have two foods one with taurine produced in a laboratory and one with natural taurine and cats are naturally drawn to the natural taurine which is found in meat and fish ingredients in Encore natural pet food.
Its important as a cat owner to be thorough and attentive when feeding a fussy cat. They will usually give clear indications as to what they enjoy and what they dont, in the same way a human does. But, just like us, they can also suffer from allergies to some food products.
Cats can also suffer with allergies and unfortunately, theres no way for them to explain to us what these are. Most cat foods are made up of multiple ingredients, so it can be difficult to diagnose exactly which one is causing the issue.
Read Also: How Old Is My 11 Year Old Cat
Best Wet Cat Food For Older Cats
Sometimes senior cats need a change in diet to make sure they are getting the right balance of calories and nutrients. Seniors may be less active than kittens or adult cats and need fewer calories in their diets.
Also, older cats are more likely to suffer from kidney problems, heart disease, and joint problems, so specially formulated foods can keep them healthier for longer.
Here are our picks for the best wet cat food for older cats:
We love this variety pack from Fancy Feast because it offers four different flavors that are all made specifically with kittens in mind. Options include Ocean Whitefish, Turkey, Chicken, and Salmon. The pate texture of these recipes make it easy for kittens to eat theseeven if their teeth are still coming in. Youll find real poultry or seafood as the first ingredient in all of the formulas and they contain a touch of milk for added richness. Plus, you really cant beat the price at under $15 for a pack of 24 cans!
If youre looking for an easy-to-serve wet kitten food, we really like the IAMS Perfect Portions. This recipe is formulated specifically for growing kittens with essential minerals like calcium for healthy bones, DHA for brain and eye development, and Vitamin E for immune system support. These trays are designed to be one feeding portion for your kittenjust snap the pack in half, peel it back, and serve.
Things to Consider
Wet Food For Picky Cats
Purina Friskies Gravy Sensations Variety Pack* six different flavors in one box, nearly one for every day of the week!
Natures Variety Instinct Original Grain Free Recipe Natural Wet Canned Cat Food* high quality ingredients and high in animal protein so that every mouthful counts.
Purina Fancy Feasts Grilled Seafood Collection Variety Pack* Purina are big hitters in the pet food industry, and they seem to be on to a popular winner with this wet food combo.
Hills Science Diet Adult Wet Cat Food* supplemented with extra vital amino acids so that picky cats with small appetites still get the best chance of good nutrition.
You May Like: Blue Buffalo Holistic Cat Food
Be Intentional About Feeding Time
Just like we humans have meal times, its important to keep your feline friends on a consistent eating schedule. Dr. Fox suggests leaving your cats food out for a timed period around 20 minutes, she says and then taking it away, so your cat will learn it has to eat at that time. If youre not around at your cats meal time, you can buy a cat feeder to do it for you. Dr. Fox recommends the PetNet Smart Feeder and the Cat Mate C20, which have automatic feeding timers that only allow your cats food to be given at a certain time.
She also advises against leaving dry food out all day, since too much grazing can lead to obesity, which can have adverse health outcomes. And just as we enjoy gathering together around the table to enjoy a meal, some cats are social eaters. If your cat is picking at its food while eating alone, try having it eat alongside another pet, or even try eating with your cat yourself to keep it company.
How Cats Choose What Cat Food They Like To Eat
Cats are drawn to certain foods by three factors: mouth feel, odor and taste, Dr. Colleran said. They learn preferences from even before birth, so some of what they like is beyond anyones control. Some variety is helpful, but it is important to look at all factors that can affect appetite, including surroundings, stress, other cats and health issues.
Dr. Vogelsang added, There are some cats who have strong preferences for flavors, textures and temperatures. For these cats, it can be more challenging to change or expand their diets. But if they learn early on that the food they receive will rotate, they will not have as great a chance to develop bad habits.
Recommended Reading: Blue Buffalo Cat Food Kitten
Make Their Food More Appetizing
If your cat wont eat its food the way it comes in the can, there are a few things you can do, according to Dr. Fox. First, you can add chicken stock or tuna water to their canned wet food to enhance the flavor. Second, try microwaving their food, since this makes it smellier. Cats actually find smelly food extra appealing.
Avoid Carrageenan Approach Xanthan Gum And Guar Gum With Caution
The most notorious cat food binder is carrageenan. While the carrageenan used in cat food is food-grade and theoretically wont cause inflammation or cancer, theres substantial evidence suggesting that food-grade carrageenan isnt as safe as it should be.
Xanthan gum is generally considered safe but might not be right for every cat. Its the product of simple sugar fermentation and may carry traces of the fermentation medium. Cats who are allergic to the soy, wheat, dairy, or corn used to make xanthan gum may have an allergic reaction. Some non-allergic cats experience diarrhea or GI discomfort after eating xanthan gum due to its high fiber content.
Recommended Reading: Can Cats Eat Chunk Light Tuna
Wellness Core Signature Selects Flaked Skipjack Tuna & Wild Salmon Entre In Broth Grain
Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Tuna, 2. Tuna Broth, 3. Mackerel, 4. Salmon, 5. Water for Processing
This recipe does absolute justice with the brand name. This signature Wellness Core recipe is made with the delicious flavors of wild salmon and flaked skipjack tuna prepared in broth. The grain-free formula is a delectable and holistic approach to your cats diet. The gourmet recipe is packed with taste and naturally delivers the variety and nutrition that your cat craves. This hand-made recipe includes delicate flakes of real tuna and many essential fatty acids to keep your cats coat and skin in peak condition. Loaded with flavors that your cat cannot resist, this food option is free from by-products, corn, wheat, and soy.
Add A Liquid Or Toppers
Wet foods are usually enough to entice picky eaters to chow down. But if that doesnt work, toppers are an excellent way to stick to your cats regular diet while giving him something new. The toppers offer an interesting twist to an old favorite food.
Liquids do the same thing. Add a little broth to your cats dry food. The liquid enhances the smell and taste of the food, enticing picky eaters to partake.
Also Check: Blue Buffalo Basics Cat
How To Deal With A Cat Thats A Picky Eater
WebMD veterinary expert answers commonly asked questions about cats and finicky eating habits.
Is your cat a picky eater that turns up their nose at almost everything you serve? Why are some cats good eaters, while others act like theyd rather starve than eat what you give them? WebMD asked Tony Buffington, a nationally known expert in feline health and nutrition, for some tips on how to keep our kitties happy and well fed. Buffington is a member and past president of the American College of Veterinary Nutrition and a professor at the College of Veterinary Medicine at Ohio State University.
Q: Why does my cat like something one day and then wont eat it the next?
A: In nature, cats are very open to trying new foods. So if a cat is finicky, something is wrong. It helps to understand how cats feed. Cats are solitary hunters. They arent pack hunters. They have a completely different evolutionary history with food than pack animals have.
In the wild, they eat between 10 and 20 meals a day, and they are opportunistic feeders. That means they eat when food is available. They hunt small prey, and those animals — small birds, mice, bugs — dont have a lot of calories. Thats why they have to eat so often.
Q: Does my cat need more than just dry food to eat? Why?
Q: Should I free feed my cat or just put food down for a short period of time?
Q: Should I cook for my cat instead of buying them food?
Q: Can a food allergy cause my cat to be a picky eater?
Fussie Cat Market Fresh Grain
This is a protein-rich best dry cat food for picky eaters manufactured and distributed by Pets Global Inc. The formula comes in a 10-pound pack and is flavored with salmon formula. If you havent noticed, cats are psychological animals and wont rush to eat anything put before them. That means their diet has to be correct and is according to their preference. Fussie Cat dry cat food is expertly prepared to meet all these conditions.
It is mainly made with essential minerals and vitamins, which promote your cats health and growth. The food is free of potato, corn, soy, wheat, and other undesirable ingredients for a picky cat. Most importantly, the food is inspected regularly for any pathogens or contamination.
Recommended Reading: Broken Tail Cat
Most Palatable Dog Foods For Picky Eaters With Images
Best cat food for picky older cats: Best dry cat food for sensitive stomach, diarrhea, and vomiting:
American journey pate turkey recipe grainfree canned cat. Also, the goodlife cat food has real chicken or.
Basics flavors natural human grade grain free food. And if it doesnt work, almost all food is guaranteed so bring it back and scratch foods off your list.
Basics flavors food topper gravy for dogs natural. As duckpond said, if your cat is eating it, thats the food you want to get.
Basics flavors food topper gravy for dogs natural. Best cat food for picky older cats:
Basics flavors food topper gravy dogs natural human grade. Best cat food for picky older cats:
Best cat food to gain weight with high calories free cat. Best dry cat food for sensitive stomach, diarrhea, and vomiting:
Bluewildernessdelightsmorselsvariety in 2020 wet cat. Best wet cat food for picky eaters:
Caru real chicken stew wet dog food 12 ounce 12 pack. Beyond this however, they can develop a possibly fatal condition called hepatic lipidosis.
Cat food review natures logic canned diet cat food. Blue buffalo indoor health natural adult dry cat food
Clear conscience pet supergravy three flavor natural pet. But i genuinely think your cats will like this food.
Clear conscience pet supergravy three flavor natural pet. Cats can become picky eaters for medical reasons that need to be determined by your veterinarian.
. Chicken, herring, turkey, and whitefish.
Weruva Cats In The Kitchen Chicken Frick A Zee
Shredded chicken and chicken broth are the top ingredients in this protein-rich wet food. Designed to be used as a complete meal or as a topper for a good kibble, the tasty broth is a great way to coax picky eaters.
Weruva Cats in the Kitchen Chicken Frick ‘A Zee
This high-protein food is all about shredded chicken in chicken broth.
Also Check: How To Keep Cat Litter From Getting Everywhere
Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Poultry & Beef Feast Variety Pack Canned Food
Top 5 Ingredients Turkey Flavored Gravy: 1. Poultry Broth, 2. Turkey, 3. Liver, 4. Chicken, 5. Meat By-ProductsChicken Flavored Gravy: 1. Poultry Broth, 2. Chicken, 3. Liver, 4. Wheat Gluten, 5. Meat By-ProductsBeef Flavored Gravy: 1. Meat Broth, 2. Beef, 3. Liver, 4. Wheat Gluten, 5. Meat By-Products
Make mealtime as scrumptious as possible with this Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Variety packs made from a delicious blend of poultry and beef. This canned cat food includes the best combos of cats favorite flavors, including beef, turkey, and chicken. What makes it more unique and irresistible for cats is its thick gourmet gravy. The tender and delicate bites are slow-cooked to perfection and feature complete and balanced nutrition for your picky eater. Packed with essential minerals and vitamins, I highly recommend this for your picky eater.
Why Is Your Picky Cat Not Eating
Your cat may not be eating for many reasons. However, having picky cats definitely makes things harder, especially when it comes to mealtimes. Here are some factors that might exacerbate food refusal.
- A lack of routine. Cats are creatures of habit and a lack of routine in their feeding schedule can be disruptive to their meal times. Free-feeding for fussy cats might not be the best idea.
- Too many treats. If youre tempting your picky cat to eat with treats, then your cat will learn that they get a reward for refusing to eat their meals.
- Picky cats often have preference for certain foods and flavours.
- The serving dish is dirty. Yes! Cats can be particular when it comes to cleanliness.
- If your cat usually eats dry food but is suddenly fussy, it may be time to replace your food supply. Dry food can absorb moisture and turn stale.
- If your cat usually eats wet food and is now refusing it, it may be that the food is too cold. Try warming it up in the microwave to room temperature, especially if it was kept in the fridge.
Read Also: Teach Kitten Not To Bite
Weruva Paw Lickin Chicken Wet Cat Food
This Weruva recipe contains only 3% carbohydrates , so if your cat likes the taste, its a healthy choice. Speaking of choice, we like the option to buy it in 3-, 5.5-, or 10-ounce cans.
Weruva Paw Lickin Chicken
Tiki Cat is renowned for recipes high in animal protein. While many of the recipes are fish-based, you will find some poultry as well, like this shredded chicken variety with 77% protein.
Tiki Cat Puka Puka Luau Succulent Chicken
Shredded chicken in chicken consommé is designed to engage even picky eaters.
Transitioning Your Cat To A New Food Tips
Dont change your cats food all at once. Start by adding small portions of the new food to your cats regular food for about 3 days. During these three days, pay close attention to your cats energy levels, bowel movements, and possible allergic reactions. Discontinue the new food if the following happens
- Skin irritation
If these symptoms go away after discontinuing, you can be sure that it is the new food causing these unwanted side effects.
If none of these symptoms occur, start adding 50% of the new food to 50% of the regular food. Return to 25% if your cat refuses to eat and try the 50/50 ratio again after a few days. Continue to monitor them for any side effects, and for the next two days, move from 50/50 to 75% new food and 25% regular food.
If all is well after two days, try 100% of the new food. Again, if your cat seems to become fussy, return to 75/25 for a bit longer and keep trying to get to 100% of the new diet.
This is the safest, most effective way of transitioning your cat to the new food, as their tummies need time to adjust to the new ingredients.
Recommended Reading: Heaviest Maine Coon Cat On Record